Comparing Asphalt Roofing & Metal Roofing

metal roofing

asphalt roofing versus metal roofingWhen you’re considering replacing a roof or installing a new one you have a variety of materials to choose from. It can be confusing as you will need to review the features of each type of material and the costs involved. Many homeowners select either metal roofing or asphalt shingles as they both offer benefits at reasonable costs. So, what things should you consider if you’re trying to decide between the two?

Well, understand that both asphalt and metal roofing are popular roofing solutions and each has their own benefits and disadvantages.

Knowing the pros and cons of the two will help you make an informed and educated choice.

Metal Roofing Pros and Cons

Nowadays metal roofs are not just used for warehouses. Metal has become popular nationwide as homeowners are installing it in greater numbers. The reasons consumers are choosing metal roofing include:


A big advantage of selecting metal is that it is long-lasting. Metal roofs can last from fifty to seventy-five years. Metal material costs more than asphalt roofing, but because of how long it lasts, it can be less expensive over time. Therefore, something to take into consideration is how long you plan to own your home.


Many homeowners decide on metal roofs based on its durability. Metal material is much more resistant to different forces which cause damages to roofing. Environmental forces that inflict damage include wind and water from rain and snow storms, fire and possibly rodents that can chew through asphalt shingles. Considering these potential damages, metal roofs are a preferred choice over asphalt shingles.

Low Maintenance

As already mentioned, metal roofing is longer-lasting and more durable than asphalt roofing. These factors lead to lower maintenance for the homeowner for a longer period of time. This gives homeowners greater peace of mind without having to deal with more frequent maintenance as time goes by. Periodic inspections to ensure all is well with your metal roof is all you will have to do.

Plenty of Choices

Metal roofing materials come in a wide variety of choices to appeal to different styles. Homeowners can select metal materials from aluminum, stainless steel, lead, zinc, copper and others. Consumers can choose based on their style preferences and cost.

Energy Efficiency

Another benefit of selecting metal roofing is it can reduce heating and cooling costs. It is a fact that metal materials deflect the sun’s ultraviolet rays, which prevents heat loss and also reduces cooling expense by an estimated ten to fifteen percent.

Environmentally Friendly

All types of metal roofing can be recycled and require significantly less energy to manufacture than other types of materials. One hundred percent of metal materials may be recycled. Due to its recyclability and energy efficiency, metal roofing is the most environmentally friendly choice.

The main deterrent from choosing metal roofing is its initial higher cost to install as in comparison to asphalt shingles. However, when homeowners weigh the benefits of long-lasting, durability and lower maintenance with metal roofing, this installation cost is not so much a disadvantage.

Asphalt Shingles Pros and Cons

Many homeowners choose asphalt shingles because they are less costly to install than metal materials and there is a wide variety of style options. As homeowners tend to not stay in one home for a longer period of time, they may see asphalt roofing as the best way to go. Therefore, something to consider is how long you anticipate living in the home versus potential maintenance and replacement costs with asphalt materials instead of metal materials. Also, homeowners who are environmentally concerned may not go with asphalt roofing as these materials are not environmentally friendly as they are less recycled.

Finally, as previously mentioned, asphalt materials do not last as long as metal roofing materials, only lasting between fifteen to twenty years and are less resistant to weather damage, especially from intense wind storms. Another consideration is the cost of homeowner’s insurance as metal roofing is more fire resistant than asphalt roofing.  

Planning a full roof replacement and in need of a roofing company in the Charlotte areaContact Southern Star Roofing today!

Call Now Button